Captain Amarinder on Punjab’s current issues and his role in BJP.....by KBS Sidhu

Chandigarh, October 26, 2024: In an in-depth interview with The Tribune that went online barely hours ago, Captain Amarinder Singh, former Chief Minister of Punjab and current BJP leader, shared his perspectives on Punjab’s paddy crisis, rising radicalism, Indo-Canada relations, and his stance on the state’s pressing political and socio-economic issues.

Conducted by The Tribune’s Editor-in-Chief Jyoti Malhotra and correspondent Ruchika Khanna, the 34-minute interview took place at Captain Singh’s scenic farmhouse, set in sylvan surroundings in Siswan near Chandigarh, marking his first public commentary since returning to Punjab after a brief hiatus.

The Paddy Crisis and AAP Government’s Handling of Procurement

Captain Amarinder Singh voiced strong concerns about the ongoing paddy crisis in Punjab, attributing the blame largely to the AAP government, led by Chief Minister Bhagwant Mann, for not addressing procurement issues effectively.He questioned the administration’s readiness and planning, noting that a proper forecast and coordination with FCI could have prevented the current backlog.

Reflecting on his time as CM, Captain Singh explained the structured procurement processes his administration followed to ensure that stocks were cleared efficiently, maintaining that this foresight and proactive approach is missing in the current governance.

Radicalism in Punjab: Captain’s Concerns

Regarding the recent rise in pro-Khalistan sentiments, Captain Amarinder Singh attributed this to an increasing wave of dissatisfaction among the youth. He explained that economic resentment and governance gaps have fostered fertile ground for radical ideas to resurface.

Captain Singh observed, however, that while radical voices are indeed loud, they represent a vocal minority rather than a larger movement within Punjab.

He pointed out the role of foreign entities in fuelling this dissent, specifically referencing Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, whom he accused of capitalising on pro-Khalistan rhetoric to secure Sikh votes in Canada.

Growing Indo-Canada Tensions and Khalistan Issue

Captain Amarinder Singh also addressed the heightened tensions between India and Canada, which stemmed from accusations against the Indian government regarding alleged espionage activities— even state-engineered aassassinations— in Canada.

He refuted these claims as unsubstantiated, dismissing the allegations as political posturing.

According to Captain Singh, Canada’s leniency towards pro-Khalistan activists, like Gurpatwant Singh Pannu, is a misguided attempt to rally Sikh votes ahead of elections, overlooking that the latter is a US citizen who resides in New York.

Insights on Drug Trafficking and Border Security

Expressing deep worry over increasing heroin smuggling across the Indo-Pak border, Captain Singh highlighted Pakistan’s strategy of “bleeding India with a thousand cuts,” aiming to destabilise Punjab by targeting its youth.

He recounted his past efforts to tackle the drug menace during his tenure as CM, such as setting up Special Investigation Teams (SITs) and pushing for collaborative efforts with central authorities. He noted, however, that drug trafficking has resurged under the current AAP administration, calling for more assertive action from both state and central governments.

Economic Discontent Among Punjab’s Farmers

Captain Amarinder Singh underscored the impact of economic distress on Punjab’s farmers, particularly in light of low basmati prices this year. He pointed out that these issues contribute to general unrest, drawing attention to farmer protests over unsatisfactory crop procurement policies, leading to a glut of paddy in Punjab mandis. Captain Singh warned that if economic grievances are not swiftly addressed, Punjab could witness a re-emergence of socio-political instability.

Upcoming By-elections: Campaigning and Health Concerns

Looking forward to the upcoming by-elections on 13 November, the former Punjab CM expressed his commitment to campaigning for the BJP, particularly in Gidderbaha, where his former finance minister, Manpreet Badal, is contesting.

Despite acknowledging health challenges due to a spine injury, he affirmed his intention to support BJP candidates and connect with Punjab’s electorate.

Analysis: Captain Amarinder Singh’s Transition and His Role in BJP’s Punjab Strategy

Captain Amarinder Singh’s political trajectory took a sharp turn when he quit the Congress Party in 2021. His exit was far from amicable. After serving as Punjab’s Chief Minister twice, he was ousted in September 2021 under circumstances many deemed unceremonious.

His swift shift to the BJP marked a major realignment as Singh sought to re-establish his political influence within a new framework.

Expectations were high, with widespread speculation that he might secure a national constitutional position, perhaps as Vice President, a senior cabinet role—likely Defence Minister—or at the very least, a gubernatorial post in a significant state. However, the BJP has extended no such offers.This restrained approach reflects the BJP’s emphasis on demonstrable political contributions over past affiliations or rhetoric.

Captain Singh’s limited sway in recent elections underscores this point. His Punjab Lok Congress, despite an alliance with the BJP and the Dhindsa faction of the Akali Dal, was soundly defeated in the 2022 state elections.

Additionally, his wife, Maharani Preneet Kaur, lost the Patiala Lok Sabha seat earlier this year on a BJP ticket—a seat she had previously held as Congress MP for three terms. These outcomes highlight the need for a stronger support base within Punjab if Captain Singh is to solidify his influence under the BJP banner.

A Subtle Disillusionment: Captain Amarinder Singh’s Unfulfilled Expectations in the BJP?

In the interview, Captain Amarinder Singh’s tone and reflections hint at an underlying disappointment with the BJP, if not a sense of disillusionment or frustration with his current political standing.

His comments reveal that, while he has had discussions with Home Minister Amit Shah, these interactions focused more on Punjab’s law-and-order issues—such as drone incursions and the drug trade—than on substantive political strategy or his role in the BJP’s plans for Punjab.

Captain Singh’s remark, “We didn’t join the BJP for fun,” encapsulates his sentiment that he, along with other former Congress leaders, joined the BJP with expectations of contributing meaningfully to its Punjab strategy and securing a proactive role in the party.

The lack of direct access to Prime Minister Modi, coupled with the BJP’s restrained approach toward placing him in a national or senior leadership position, reinforces a sense that his contributions have not yet been fully recognised.

Captain Amrinder Singh’s statements reflect a complex mix of loyalty and unease, suggesting he may feel constrained, if not somewhat sidelined, within the BJP. This is underscored by his assertion that leaders of his stature bring experience and understanding that should be acknowledged—a point that feels more like a reminder to the BJP than a casual observation.

Cautious Optimism for Captain Amarinder Singh’s Next Phase

While Captain Amarinder Singh’s political journey now appears to be in a reflective stage, his unwavering “never-say-die” spirit suggests he is far from conceding his position.

His seasoned experience, dedication to Punjab, and alliance with the BJP may yet enable him to play a meaningful role in shaping the state’s future. The upcoming by-elections offer him an opportunity to reinvigorate his influence, especially in Gidderbaha, where his former Finance Minister Manpreet Badal is contesting on a BJP ticket. Should he succeed in mobilising effectively, Captain Singh could still prove to be an asset for the BJP’s efforts in Punjab.

With health challenges to navigate, his future trajectory remains uncertain but keenly anticipated. Punjab, its people, and the nation will be watching closely as he embraces this next chapter, buoyed by cautious optimism and a soldier’s tenacity.

October 26, 2024