Shining Digital Boards, Dusty Government Offices: Punjab’s Unfinished Administrative Reform .. Colonel Jasjit Singh Gill (retd.) | Ludhiana-based Environmental activist
Forty-four years after the pioneering Lakhina Model, Punjab’s administrative offices still struggle with elementary cleanliness, record management and dignity at work. Digital governance cannot succeed while its physical foundations remain neglected.
Even today, officers of the Indian Administrative Service (IAS) and other civil services study the celebrated Lakhina Model of administrative reform, pioneered in 1982 by Anil Kumar Lakhina, a 1974-batch Maharashtra-cadre IAS officer, during his tenure as District Collector of Ahmednagar.
Interestingly, Lakhina had close connections with Punjab. He obtained his Bachelor of Laws degree from Panjab University, Chandigarh, while his maternal grandfather, Mulkraj Mehta, owned an electricity powerhouse in Moga before establishing another in Narela. His parents had migrated at Partition from what became Pakistan. Thus, although Lakhina served in the Maharashtra cadre, his family history and education connected him with Punjab.
His celebrated administrative experiment was remarkably straightforward. He reorganised government offices, cleared accumulated clutter, improved record management, simplified procedures, made offices more accessible to citizens and, above all, recognised that the working environment of ordinary government employees was fundamental to administrative efficiency.
The experiment attracted national attention. Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi subsequently encouraged the States to send district officers for training in the model, and Lakhina received the Padma Shri in 1986.
Forty-four years later, despite computers, eOffice, Sewa Kendras, digitised land records and gleaming electronic display boards proclaiming governmental achievements, Punjab’s administrative offices present a troubling contradiction.
Walk into the office of a Cabinet Minister, Deputy Commissioner or Sub-Divisional Magistrate in Punjab, and you are likely to find a well-maintained, air-conditioned and spotlessly clean environment.
But walk barely twenty paces down the same corridor, into the branches occupied by Superintendents, Assistants and Clerks, and the picture can change dramatically.
Heaps of yellowing paper files, tied with fading red tape, occupy dusty floors, rusty steel almirahs and windowsills. Broken furniture, obsolete computers, tangled electrical wires and discarded equipment compete for space with employees attempting to discharge their official duties.
In many tehsil, sub-tehsil and block offices, conditions can be worse.
Ordinary citizens must navigate congested corridors and overcrowded rooms to complete routine revenue and administrative transactions. Meanwhile, thousands of employees spend eight or nine hours daily in surroundings that would scarcely be tolerated in the chambers of their senior officers.
Punjab has invested considerable public money in impressive District Administrative Complexes and digital infrastructure. Yet it continues to overlook a fundamental principle of public administration:
Clean and efficient administration cannot flourish in dirty, disorderly and unhealthy workplaces.
Cleanliness Cannot Be Reserved for Senior Officers
Professional housekeeping often seems to stop at the doors of senior officers.
In many branches, Class IV employees are already overburdened with moving files, attending to visitors and performing miscellaneous duties, including serving tea and refreshments.
Consequently, thorough cleaning of corners, cupboards, windows, storage spaces and workstations receives little attention.
Desktops may be wiped daily, but accumulated dust on files and furniture can remain undisturbed for months, sometimes years.
Punjab’s naturally dusty environment, compounded by agricultural activity and seasonal air pollution, makes regular cleaning and dust control particularly important. Poorly maintained offices can expose employees to allergens and other airborne irritants, adversely affecting their comfort, health and productivity.
The condition of staff toilets and public conveniences in many tehsil and block offices adds another dimension to the problem.
Why should a Deputy Commissioner’s washroom be spotless while clerks and members of the public in the same administrative complex must endure poorly maintained facilities?
Cleanliness is not a privilege attached to rank. It is a fundamental workplace requirement.
The Mountains of Files and the Culture of Administrative Neglect
A second major problem is the accumulation of unnecessary material.
Broken swivel chairs, rusting cupboards, abandoned dot-matrix printers, obsolete computer monitors and mountains of paper records occupy valuable office space.
Government procedures for inventory verification, condemnation and disposal of unserviceable items are often so cumbersome that officers prefer to postpone the exercise indefinitely.
Consequently, government offices gradually become storage yards for equipment and records that should have been disposed of years earlier.
This is precisely the kind of administrative inertia that the Lakhina Model sought to overcome in Ahmednagar in 1982.
There is also a neglected human dimension.
Many employees have no clean, designated space in which to eat lunch or take a short tea break. Tiffin boxes are opened on desks crowded with jamabandis, cash books, registers and dusty files.
Providing a modest, hygienic pantry or lunch area is hardly an extravagant demand. It is a simple recognition that government employees are human beings entitled to dignity at work.
Digitisation Has Not Eliminated the Paper Mountain
Punjab has undoubtedly made progress in digitising public services, particularly land records and citizen-facing administrative transactions.
However, substantial volumes of physical records continue to exist in government offices.
Some documents must be preserved because of statutory requirements, pending litigation, investigations, audit objections or their enduring legal and administrative significance.
These records cannot simply be discarded in the name of cleanliness.
Equally, they cannot be left lying unsecured on floors, exposed shelves or open corridors, where they risk damage from moisture, termites, fire or unauthorised handling.
Government departments must distinguish between records requiring permanent preservation, those subject to prescribed retention periods and those eligible for lawful destruction.
Important physical records should be transferred to secure, properly indexed, fire-resistant central storage facilities, with controlled access and clear responsibility for their custody.
Similarly, digitisation must mean more than merely scanning documents onto individual computers.
Government records require secure, government-approved centralised storage, reliable backups, controlled access, audit trails and safeguards against unauthorised alteration or loss.
The objective must be to make records both secure and readily retrievable, rather than merely shifting the clutter from paper cupboards to computer hard drives.
After all, an electronic file that cannot be located, authenticated or retrieved when required is hardly an improvement over a dusty paper file.
A Clean and Functional Offices Mission for Punjab
Punjab does not need another generation of expensive administrative buildings to solve this problem.
What it needs is political commitment, administrative accountability and a relatively modest budgetary allocation.
A Clean and Functional Offices Mission, implemented across the Civil Secretariat, district headquarters, tehsils, sub-tehsils and block offices, could substantially improve working conditions within a single financial year.
The Mission should have four clearly defined components.
1. Stocktaking, Weeding and Disposal
Every government office should undertake a comprehensive, time-bound stocktaking exercise, beginning with a 30-day inventory of records, furniture and equipment.
Unserviceable items should be condemned and disposed of through prescribed procedures. Obsolete files should be weeded out strictly in accordance with applicable record-retention rules.
In severely cluttered offices, reclaiming 15–20 per cent of usable floor space could be a reasonable initial target, subject to physical assessment.
There is little justification for retaining broken chairs, abandoned computers and unusable furniture indefinitely merely because their disposal requires administrative approval.
2. Modern Filing and Secure Storage
Open, rusting cupboards should progressively give way to sealed modular storage systems.
Frequently used files must be systematically indexed and easily accessible. Sensitive and legally significant records should be housed in secure central record rooms with appropriate fire protection, moisture control and access safeguards.
Windows and storage areas should be improved to minimise dust ingress, while digital records should be maintained on secure government-approved systems.
Computerisation and proper physical record management must complement each other.
3. Professional Housekeeping
Professional housekeeping services should be introduced wherever existing arrangements are inadequate, through appropriate outsourcing or properly staffed departmental systems, with clearly defined service standards and regular inspections.
Every clerical branch, records room, corridor, public waiting area and toilet should meet prescribed cleanliness standards.
The standard applied to the Deputy Commissioner’s office should also apply to the rooms occupied by Superintendents, Assistants, Clerks and other employees.
Housekeeping contracts should be monitored for actual performance, not merely processed for payment.
4. Dignity and Welfare of Employees
Every administrative complex should provide clean drinking water, hygienic toilets, adequate ventilation, safe electrical installations, functional furniture and a modest space for employees to eat or take short breaks.
These are not luxuries. They are the minimum requirements of a modern workplace.
Progress under the Mission should be reviewed periodically, with measurable benchmarks and responsibility assigned to designated officers.
District-level inspections should cover the entire administrative establishment, not merely the offices occupied by its senior leadership.
Ending VIP Culture Must Begin Inside Government Offices
Punjab speaks frequently about eliminating VIP culture. Yet one of its most visible manifestations survives within government buildings themselves.
On one side of a corridor sits a senior officer in a polished, air-conditioned chamber. On the other side, clerks and assistants work amid dust, obsolete furniture and overflowing files.
This contradiction cannot be justified by differences in seniority or official responsibility.
A Superintendent, Assistant or Clerk may not exercise the powers of a Deputy Commissioner, but that does not diminish the employee’s right to a clean and dignified workplace.
Nor should citizens seeking ordinary government services have to navigate conditions that the administration itself would not tolerate in its senior officers’ chambers.
If government expects employees to deliver courteous, timely and efficient services, it must first provide them with the necessary working conditions.
There is a direct connection between the manner in which an organisation treats its employees and the quality of service those employees are encouraged and equipped to provide.
The Lakhina Model demonstrated this principle in Ahmednagar in 1982, long before computers, electronic files and digital governance became fashionable.
It is particularly ironic that Punjab, with which Lakhina had educational and family connections, should still need reminding of reforms that received national recognition more than four decades ago.
Administrative modernisation cannot be measured merely by the number of computers installed, services placed online or electronic achievement boards illuminating government buildings.
The true measure lies in the condition of the room where the ordinary clerk works, the efficiency with which a file can be retrieved, the security of public records, the cleanliness of public facilities and the dignity with which an ordinary citizen is received.
A government office cannot claim to be truly modern merely because its signboard is digital while its working environment remains trapped in another century.
Punjab should revive the spirit of the Lakhina Model—not as another ceremonial announcement or administrative slogan, but as a practical, measurable campaign to transform every government workplace.
The real test of good governance is not how brightly the government’s achievements shine on an electronic board, but how cleanly, efficiently and humanely the administration functions behind it.
-

-
Col Jasjit Gill, Rtd Army Officer/ Environment Activist
jassgill44@gmail.com
Phone No. : +91-9914459161
Disclaimer : The opinions expressed within this article are the personal opinions of the writer/author. The facts and opinions appearing in the article do not reflect the views of Babushahi.com or Tirchhi Nazar Media. Babushahi.com or Tirchhi Nazar Media does not assume any responsibility or liability for the same.